The Writing Life Review

Annie Dillard’s small, fierce book survives her

This post contains affiliate links. If you buy through them, I may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. Full disclosure policy.

This post contains affiliate links. If you buy through them, I may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. Full disclosure policy.

Bottom line: The Writing Life is a short collection of essays about what writing actually costs: the hours, the false starts, the paragraphs you love but have to cut. Dillard writes about it with the attention she brought to muskrats and moths in Pilgrim at Tinker Creek. So the result reads like a field guide to your own worst workday, but that’s a good thing. It isn’t a how-to book, so readers looking for a craft system may feel frustrated. Dillard herself later disowned most of the book. For any writer who needs to hear that the struggle is the job, it’s still essential.

Scribbright rating: 4.5 out of 5

→ See all writing craft books reviewed at Scribbright.

A book about writing from someone who never pretended it was easy

When Annie Dillard died at her home in South Wellfleet, Massachusetts at the age of 81, most obituaries I saw led with Pilgrim at Tinker Creek. Understandable, since it won the Pulitzer Prize for General Nonfiction in 1975. But a lot of working writers met her through a much smaller book. It’s one they keep coming back to on bad days.

That book is The Writing Life. It runs 128 pages, readable in an afternoon, will be a go-to resource for, oh, the next 20 years or so.

It’s not a pick-me-up. Her point of view is that writing is slow, solitary work that mostly goes wrong, and the only way through is to keep showing up. She describes working in a library carrel with the view deliberately blocked, because a window is a standing invitation to stop (which reminds me of Jonathan Franzen in his little rental office with a laptop whose ports are epoxied shut). She describes sentences that take a morning to get sort of right, and pages that take a lot longer. She compares sentences to a tool you swing at the unknown, and she never promises it’ll hit anything.

I first read it at a point in my career when I believed a good enough outline would save me. Not so. Dillard would’ve told me that and in fact did, right at the start of this book.

What’s inside

The book is seven short chapters, each circling the same question: what does it feel like to make something out of nothing, every day, with no guarantee? Dillard meanders between Cape Cod, a cabin on an island in Puget Sound, and that library carrel. Typewriters, chess, splitting wood, and a moth drawn into a candle flame all put in an appearance. It sounds scattered but it isn’t. Each detail ends up being salient to the work.

It’s her plain advice that survives decades of rereading. Like her advice to spend your best material now rather than saving it for a later book, because hoarding makes it rot. A student asked her if she thought they could be a writer; her answer, roughly, was that it depends on if they like sentences. That sounds simple, and it is, but it’s far from simplistic.

Her best-known line from the book may be “how we spend our days is, of course, how we spend our lives.” It shows up on mugs and in email signatures, a weird afterlife for a sentence that was actually a warning about procrastination.

The chapter she didn’t disown

The book ends with the story of Dave Rahm, a stunt pilot Dillard watched perform aerobatics in the Pacific Northwest. It’s the finest writing in the collection. But it’s scarcely about writing at all. Rahm’s flying becomes her vision of art as dangerous, precise, and gone the moment it’s finished.

According to a biography written by her husband, Robert D. Richardson, Dillard later repudiated The Writing Life except for that final chapter. This may be perfectly in character. She wrote one of the most quoted books about the craft and then decided a lot of it didn’t meet her standards.

She wrote about nature and won her Pulitzer for it, but resisted the “nature writer” label her whole career and largely stepped back from public life after 2007. Her work didn’t need her to promote it. Writers kept her books alive.

If you’ve never read her, The Writing Life is the place to start. And it’s ideal if your job revolves around a blank page.

Who it’s for

Working writers in a slump will get the most from it, because Dillard makes the slump feel like part of the process instead of a verdict. MFA students and creative writing teachers will find it an essential, for good reason. Nonfiction writers and essayists will learn from her style and approach as much as her advice. If you want a structured craft manual with exercises, pair it with something practical like Dreyer’s English instead of relying on it alone.

Pros

• Short enough to reread every year, and it rewards rereading
• Honest about how hard and slow real writing is
• Prose so precise it doubles as a style lesson
• The Dave Rahm chapter alone is worth the cover price
• Inexpensive paperback that’s been in print for decades

Cons

• No practical system, exercises, or step-by-step advice
• Some middle chapters drift into loosely connected images
• Its romantic view of solitary labor won’t suit every writer’s life
• The author herself disowned most of it, which is awkward to know going in

The verdict

The Writing Life won’t tell you how to write. It tells you what it’s like to write, which is actually useful to hear on a day when nothing’s working. Dillard spent her career paying close attention to the world and then to her sentences, and this book is where she turned that attention to the job itself. She’s gone now. The book is still 128 pages, still cheap, and still right about most things, whatever she thought of it later.

Michael Semer is a professional writer and editor with 40 years of experience in advertising, B2B content marketing, and digital publishing. He lent out a copy of this book in 1988 and still holds it against the person who didn’t return it.

FAQ

Is The Writing Life a how-to book?

No. It’s a collection of personal essays about the experience of writing: the discipline, the doubt, and the long stretches where nothing works. Readers who want exercises or structure should pair it with a practical craft or style guide.

How long is The Writing Life?

The Harper Perennial paperback runs 128 pages. Most readers finish it in one or two sittings, though it tends to get reread slowly afterward.

When did Annie Dillard die?

Annie Dillard died in September 2026 at her home in South Wellfleet, Massachusetts. She was 81 and was best known for Pilgrim at Tinker Creek, which won the 1975 Pulitzer Prize for General Nonfiction.

What is the Dave Rahm chapter about?

The final chapter tells the true story of Dave Rahm, a stunt pilot whose aerobatic performances Dillard watched and admired. She uses his flying as a picture of art at its most daring and exact. It’s widely considered the strongest writing in the book.

Which Annie Dillard book should I read after The Writing Life?

Pilgrim at Tinker Creek is the natural next step, since it shows the attention she describes in The Writing Life at full strength. Teaching a Stone to Talk, which includes her essay “Total Eclipse,” is a good choice if you prefer shorter pieces.

→ See all desk gear reviewed at Scribbright.